This module focused on cognitive development and how it is
related to learning. Constructivism was a major theme of this module, and
different constructivist theories were discussed. The main theories that were
discussed were Piaget’s Theory and Vygotsky’s Theory. Piaget proposed an idea
of genetic epistemology, which is the idea that knowledge develops from an
interaction between nature and nurture. Piaget states that all children’s
thinking evolves from biological maturation, active exploration of the physical
environment, social experiences, and equilibration. Piaget also states that
there are four stages of development- sensorimotor, pre-operational, concrete operational
and formal operational. Each stage has specific characteristics, though
learning is continually happening, even between stages.
Vygotsky believed that cognitive development resulted from
an interaction between environment and heredity. He also emphasized the
importance of social interactions. Zygotsky came up with the Zone of Proximal
Development, which is the difference between what an individual can accomplish
independently and what he or she can learn with assistance from more capable
individuals. Vygotsky believed learning (especially in school) helps children’s
development gradually move from one level to the next. Both Vygotsky and Piaget
argued that play was extremely important in children’s cognitive development.
Teachers can apply cognitive development in many ways.
First, they can keep in mind the students’ different levels of thinking , especially
when it comes to making lesson plans or thinking of projects. Teachers can also
encourage play (which may only work in younger grades), and could encourage
students who are exceptionally well at a certain subject or task to work with
students who are so good, which is based on Vygotsky’s idea of scaffolding.
What is the main difference between Piaget’s and Vygotsky’s
theories?
According to Piaget, development precedes learning, because
an individual must be developmentally ready to learn. Development involves
acquiring concepts spontaneously through natural experiences, and learning
involves applying those newly developed cognitive structures to new situations.
The developmental stage that the child is in directly determines what he or she
is able to learn. A brain researcher would say that learning is caused by
making neural connections in the brain and myleinating those connections.
According to Piaget, critical thinking would not push
development. Piaget believed that development precedes learning. He stated that
an individual must be developmentally ready to learn. Piaget’s theory focuses on
stages, specific characteristics, and objectives that are reached before moving
on to the next stage. Because of this, development would not be pushed by
critical thinking. If a child is not developmentally ready for the type of
thinking, they will not gain or learn anything from it. Using the example from
class today, if a young child is given a riddle that requires “out-of-the-box”
and critical thinking, they will not develop from it at all if they are not
developmentally ready to tackle such a riddle or task.
In response to your question, I think that the main difference between Piaget's and Vygotsky's models is that Piaget's is based strictly on age and Vygotsky's is based more on what a child has achieved and will achieved. Vygotsky does not limit children to only learning certain concepts at certain ages.
ReplyDeleteI think that the main differences between the two theories are that Piaget is based on development preceding learning and taking place in specific stages where as Vygotsky is more concerned about the difference in actual development and potential. Vygotsky would say that children are developing as they difference between the actual development and the potential decreases. Piaget would say that development happens as children advance through his stages of development.
ReplyDeleteYou distinguish development and learning (for Piaget) with "Development involves acquiring concepts spontaneously through natural experiences, and learning involves applying those newly developed cognitive structures to new situations." I'm not sure I understand this part. I think Piaget woudn't think you can spontaneously acquire concepts--it always involves active construction. This active construction (of schema) would be learning. But, as you say in your last paragraph (which I like) you need to be developmentally ready for this learning.
ReplyDelete