One question I had about the chapter is do mixed-ability groups allow for high-achieving students to excel, as they would if they were in an all high-ability group?
Vygotsky and grouping go hand in hand because Vygotsky believes that one cannot learn or develop individually. Vygotsky believes that one cannot learn without outside influences like people, culture and environment. Vygotsky would most likely agree with heterogeneous grouping because that gives some students the ability to reach places intellectually that they would otherwise not reach in a group that is homogeneous.
Vygotsky and Piaget differ because Vygotsky takes more of a social approach to learning and development. According to Vygotsky, development takes place on a much larger scale, and learning helps to speed up development. Piaget has four stages in which learning does not speed up or hinder development. Vygotsky talks about environment and culture greatly influencing the developmental process, whereas Piaget doesn't have such a social approach.
Right now, I am sitting in my living room with my roommate, watching TV. My learning is being influenced a the moment by my roommate sharing ideas, and the textbook. The TV is also somewhat distracting, they are not teaching me anything.
I do believe that they will still be able to excel because they are helping the lower achieving students which allows them to think about the subject matter in a different way and when they explain it to the lower achieving students they are able to fully understand all of the ways to look at the subject matter.
ReplyDelete